Few arguments are more tiresome than the one about experts. One side says that we must trust them; the other says that they have been wrong too often to deserve it. Both sides speak as if expertise were a single substance that one either has faith in or does not.
What experts actually know
Expertise is narrower and more useful than either side admits. An expert knows what has been tried before, what tends to go wrong, which questions are genuinely open and which only appear to be. That is enormously valuable. It is not the same as knowing what we should do, which depends on values, trade-offs and risks that no specialism can settle on its own.
The real failure
When expertise fails publicly, it is usually because this distinction has been blurred — because a judgement about values was presented as a finding of fact, or because uncertainty was hidden in the name of clarity. The cure is not to trust experts less, but to ask them better questions, and to expect them to say plainly where their knowledge ends.
A healthy democracy needs both expertise and argument. It goes wrong when it confuses one for the other.



